Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter



Succos Trips, With and Without a Succah

Rabbi Yitzchak Tzvi Ushinski

Many people view the days of Chol HaMoed Succos as an opportunity to enjoy pleasure trips and other types of excursions. Oftentimes, however, no succah is available at the destination of these outings, raising the halachic question of whether it is permitted to eat outside a succah in reliance on the Gemara’s statement that traveler are exempt from the mitzvah of succah. We will explore a trip that will require eating outside a succah is appropriate, as well as if it is proper for pleasure trips at all.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

The Gemara (Succah 26a) states: “People who travel by day are exempt from succah during the day but are obligated at night. People who travel by night are exempt from succah at night but are obligated during the day. People who travel both during the day and at night are exempt from succah both during the day and at night.”

Why are travelers exempt from the requirement of succah? Rashi explains that the Torah states, “You shall live in succos for seven days,” and Chazal interpret this as “teishvu k’ein taduru,” i.e., a person should live in the succah in the same manner in which he lives in his home. Thus, just as a person does not refrain from leaving his home during the year to take a business trip, the Torah does not require a person to refrain from taking a trip during Succos either, even though it will mean that he will not be able to live in his succah.

Indeed, the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 640:8) rules in accordance with the Gemara’s statement: “People who travel by day are exempt from succah during the day and are obligated at night. People who travel at night are exempt at night and obligated during the day.”

 

Daytime Travels, Nighttime Succah

Is a person who travels during the day obligated to build a succah at night if an existing one isn’t readily available? This question is the subject of a dispute between early halachic authorities (cited in Biur Halachah, sec. 640; Chayei Adam, klal 147 sec. 22; and Shu”t Yechaveh Daas by Rav Ovadiah Yosef shlita, vol. 3 sec. 47). While the Gemara indicates that people who are traveling only during the day are obligated to observe the mitzvah of succah at night, Levush maintains that this is true only in the event that a succah is already available in the place where they are staying over. If there is no succah there, however, Chazal did not require travelers to go to the trouble of erecting one in which to sleep for the night. Magen Avraham, however, disagrees with Levush and rules that daytime travelers must even fabricate a succah at night if a ready-made one is not available. 

Chayei Adam rules in accordance with Levush, reasoning that requiring a traveler to build a succah would entail hours of strenuous labor, an imposition that certainly does not fit the criterion of “teishvu k’ein taduru.” Chayei Adam finds support for this ruling  in the commentary of Meiri (Succah 26a), who  writes that a traveler is not obligated to build a succah at night, although if he finds himself in a place where there is a succah, he is not permitted to eat or sleep outside it. Rav Ovadiah Yosef rules that the halachah follows the opinion of Levush and Chayei Adam.

 

To read the rest of this story, please buy this issue of Mishpacha or sign up for a weekly subscription.

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.
CAPTCHA
Message


MM217
 
What’s in a Name?
Shoshana Friedman “What does Writer X have to say this week?”
Atonement — Fake and Real
Yonoson Rosenblum White confessionals and faux rituals
Four Walls Coming Full Circle
Eytan Kobre All the while, there’s been a relationship in the offing...
And Yet We Smile
Yisroel Besser We are the nation that toils to be happy at all costs
Out of This World
Rabbi Henoch Plotnick Dirshu Hashem b’himatzo — we are in Hashem’s company now...
Steven and Jonathan Litton
Rachel Bachrach The co-owners of Litton Sukkah, based in Lawrence, NY
Tali Messing
Moe Mernick Tali Messing, engineering manager at Facebook Tel Aviv
Sick Note
Jacob L. Freedman “Of course, Dr. Freedman. Machul, machul, machul”
Avoiding Health Columns Can Be Good for You
Rabbi Emanuel Feldman Only one reliable guide for good health: our Torah
Endnote: Side Notes
Riki Goldstein Most Jewish music industry entertainers have side profes...
Me, Myself, and Why
Faigy Peritzman Where there’s no heart and no love, there’s no point
Can’t Do It Without You
Sarah Chana Radcliffe When you step up to the plate, you build your home team
Eternal Joy
Mrs. Elana Moskowitz The joy of Succos is the fruit of spiritual victory
The Appraiser: Part III
D. Himy, M.S. CCC-SLP and Zivia Reischer Make sure your child knows his strengths
Hidden Special Needs
Rena Shechter You won’t see his special needs, but don’t deny them
Dear Wealthy Friend
Anonymous There’s no need for guilt. I am truly happy for you