Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter



Who Wrote the Last Eight Psukim of the Torah?

Rabbi Shimshon Nadel

As Jews, we believe fundamentally in the divinity and immutable authority of our Holy Torah. According to the Rambam, another fundamental principle is that the entire Torah was written by Moshe Rabbeinu. How, then, are we to understand the last eight psukim of the Torah, which begin, “And Moshe, servant of Hashem, died there”? If he had already died, how could Moshe have written these words?

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

 Chazal, too, were bothered by this question and discuss the authorship of this passage in two places in the Talmud Bavli.[i] There exists a machlokes Tanna’im as to who wrote the last eight psukim of the Torah: Rabi Yehudah (some say Rabi Nechemiah) states that while up until this point, the Torah was written by Moshe, the last eight psukim were written by Yehoshua. Rabi Shimon contends that the last eight psukim were dictated by Hashem, and Moshe wrote them b’dimah with tears. Both opinions suggest that these last eight psukim are unique.

The Vilna Gaon explains that Rabi Yehudah and Rabi Shimon are actually in agreement with one another[ii] The Torah, before its revelation at Sinai, existed in the form of combinations and permutations of letters and words, resulting in the formation of many different Names of Hashem.[iii] This “proto-Torah,” in its pristine state, was given to Moshe, who then “revealed” the Torah that we have today and committed it to writing. The Gaon explains that the word “dimah” in this context means combined or mixed together. He suggests that Moshe brought down the last eight psukim, but left them in their mixed (or hidden) state because it would not have been truthful to write explicitly “And Moshe, servant of Hashem, died there” while Moshe was still alive. They were then revealed and committed to writing by Yehoshua, following Moshe’s death. According to this explanation, even Rabi Yehudah agrees that Moshe was involved in the transmission of the last eight psukim and thus is considered to have written the entire sefer Torah.

 



[i] Bava Basra 15a; Menachos 30a; Cf. Sifrei, V’zos HaBrachah, piska 357. See also Makkos 11a,Aruch LaNer, ad loc., and Ibn Ezra to Devarim 34:1, who writes that Yehoshua wrote the last twelve psukim of the Torah.

[ii] Kol Eliyahu, V’zos HaBrachah; Divrei Eliyahu, Bava Basra 15a. A similar approach is cited by Kli Chemdah to Devarim 34:5 in the name of the Rema Mi’Fano.

[iii] See Ramban’s introduction to his Commentary to the Torah; Cf. Zohar, Yisro 87a.

 

To read the rest of this story, please buy this issue of Mishpacha or sign up for a weekly subscription.

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.
CAPTCHA
Message


 
Top-Down Theory
Shoshana Friedman Our true currency, the accomplishments we value most
Strive for What Binds Us
Yonoson Rosenblum The chareidi community represents something of an oasis
Embracing Victimhood
Eytan Kobre Combating the allure of victimhood
The Kids Are Going to Camp, the Parents Are Going Broke
Miriam Klein Adelman Mindy has to feel good; it doesn’t matter that I feel ba...
Work/Life Solutions with Carlos Wigle
Moe Mernick “Rejection is Hashem’s protection” 
How to Create a Simple 900-Page Novel
Rabbi Emanuel Feldman All of us can reset the titles of our own lives
Stand There or Do Something
Baruch S. Fertel, MD, MPA, FACEP It’s called collaborative care, and it works miracles
I'm Here — Are You Ready?
Riki Goldstein Upbeat and catchy, but still makes listeners think
Back in Time
Riki Goldstein "I wish I could recapture that excitement"
Mixed Messages
Riki Goldstein The unsung craftsmen who give albums their special touch
Go in Peace
Faigy Peritzman Inner peace makes us vessels for blessing
All Work and No Play
Sarah Chana Radcliffe A life only about doing your duties loses all its color
Dying to Believe
With Rav Moshe Wolfson, written by Baila Vorhand Emunah peshutah is the force behind Jewish continuity