Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter

From Dust to Ashes

Shimmy Blum

Ethel Baar could have been buried next to her dear friend, and her closest relatives contend this was indeed her final wish. However, a New York Supreme Court judge ruled that Mrs. Baar should be cremated in accordance with her written will. The people responsible for the intense and prolonged effort to give Mrs. Baar, who died at 105, the dignity of a Jewish burial believe that increased awareness of end-of-life and postmortem issues can help spare others from suffering a similar fate.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

One Jewish woman’s celebrated lifetime of 105 years was capped by a heartbreaking, final degradation last week in an emotionally charged lower Manhattan courtroom.

New York State Supreme Court Justice Jane Solomon’s decision to reaffirm her previous order to cremate the remains of Ethel Baar ended a months-long drama that saw an acrimonious dispute, replete with anti-religious overtones, flare between Mrs. Baar’s kin.

The fierce legal tug-of-war following Ethel’s death was the final chapter of a struggle over her postmortem wishes that had begun during her lifetime. Ethel, who was raised in a religious home, left observance as a young woman, and she and her late husband, Jacob, spent their many decades of married life together in Manhattan living a secular lifestyle and had no children of their own. In 1987, Jacob died and his wish to have his remains cremated — with his ashes to be dispersed over Israel’s soil — was fulfilled.

In 1999, the then-ninety-four-year-old Mrs. Baar designated her nephew, attorney Leibert Greenberg, a secular Jew, as the fiduciary and beneficiary of her estate, and drafted a will stating her desire to be cremated. Greenberg subsequently made a “pre-need” cremation arrangement with Gramercy Park Funeral Home in Manhattan.

In 2004, Ethel was visited by her frum great-nephew, James (Yitzchok) Pollock, and his new wife. Ethel enjoyed an unusually close relationship with James, who spent three years living in her apartment during the late 1990s when she was a fragile, elderly widow. Ethel told Mrs. Pollock that her husband was like the son she never had. During their visit, the couple gingerly broached the topic of Ethel’s cremation wish. They explained to her their desire to be able, after 120 years, to have a gravesite to visit and be able to recite the Kaddish for her. Mr. Pollock assured his great-aunt that he would attend to all the details of a Jewish funeral and burial, and was even prepared to cover the costs involved.    

At the time, Ethel rejected the Pollocks’ pleas, though in his affidavit to the court, Pollock asserted that Ethel later had a change of heart and agreed to a proper Jewish burial. Pollock’s account was corroborated by Ethel Gordon, daughter of Ethel’s best friend, the late Bashka Schasberger, and Conservative clergyman Simon Hirschhorn, the Jewish chaplain at the Hebrew Home for the Aged in Riverdale, where Ethel spent her final years. Mrs. Gordon offered Ethel the plot adjoining that of her own mother at no cost. In written testimony, Pollock stated that he obtained Ethel’s permission to instruct Mr. Greenberg to amend the will to reflect her desire for burial, but was ignored by the fiduciary, and even produced one of the emails he had sent to the fiduciary as evidence of his contention.


To read the rest of this story, please buy this issue of Mishpacha or sign up for a weekly subscription.

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.

No Misunderstandings
Rabbi Moshe Grylak Hashem revealed the secret of a balanced life
What Was the Court’s Rush?
Yonoson Rosenblum The Democratic Party’s descent into madness
Survey? Oy Vey
Eytan Kobre How could YAFFED promote such a farce?
Filling the Void
Rabbi Henoch Plotnik Jewish leaders don’t need to be declared or coronated
Top 5 Ways We Remember Our Rebbeim (and we love them for it!)
Rabbi Dovid Bashevkin An ode to these pivotal people in my life
Hanging On in Newark
Rabbi Nosson Scherman Rabbi Nosson Scherman remembers the shul of his youth
A Fine Kettle of Fish
Rabbi Ron Yitzchok Eisenman The “minor” chasadim are often the most meaningful
The Next Hill
Jacob L. Freedman The look on Malachi’s face nearly broke my heart
Tradition and Modern Meet in One Long Dance
Riki Goldstein Fusing tradition and modernity comes naturally to him
A Playlist for Shabbos
Riki Goldstein What does Moshy Kraus sing at the Shabbos table?
With Flying Colors
Riki Goldstein My 15 seconds of fame on the Carnegie Hall stage
Full Faith
Faigy Peritzman With emunah, everyone’s obligation is the same
Sarah Chana Radcliffe Silence isn’t always golden
The Only One
With Rav Moshe Wolfson, written by Baila Vorhand Within every Jew is the flame of instinctive emunah