Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter
Five prominent figures in the worlds of Orthodox Jewish journalism and communal leadership address some of the challenges and opportunities
Wednesday, April 05, 2017
R ecent decades have seen a quantitative and qualitative burgeoning of the Torah-observant community in America, which in turn has led to a growing engagement with the political, business, and certain other spheres of the larger American society. At the same time, this community has developed a robust journalistic sector, featuring numerous daily and weekly newspapers and magazines catering to the entire spectrum of the Orthodox community.
Mishpacha has brought together five prominent figures in the worlds of journalism and communal leadership to address some of the challenges and opportunities that these developments present for the Orthodox world. In considering these issues, our panelists were asked to select from several questions and share their thoughts about these modern-day dilemmas
In what ways, if any, does the role of a frum journalist differ from that of a secular one? What particular strengths and drawbacks does a religious journalist bring to his work?
Is it for the frum journalist to hold institutions of general society such as government, industry and business, media, etc., accountable? Is it for the frum journalist to hold the particular institutions of Orthodox Jewish society accountable?
What news is, or is not, “fit to print” in the Torah view? Does a frum readership have a “right to know,” or perhaps a “right not to know”? Are we aiming for news that disturbs or confirms our previously held views? Broadens or bolsters our boundaries?
It is considered axiomatic that, at least as an ideal, journalists are expected to strive for objectivity. In the case of the frum journalist, who answers to the Torah’s standards, is it indispensable, desirable or perhaps objectionable to allow his Jewish worldview to color the way he reports the news? Could a case be made that news reporting as it currently exists in the world at large, in which G-d is absent from the picture, is inherently at odds with Torah?
Rabbi Sheftel Meir Neuberger, a talmid of Yeshiva Ner Israel since 1959, served as a maggid shiur in the yeshivah from 1973 through 1986, when he became the executive assistant to his revered father, Rabbi Herman N. Neuberger z”l. Upon his father’s passing in 2005, he assumed his position as president and menahel of the yeshivah.
Jeff Jacoby is a longtime columnist for the Boston Globe and a nationally recognized conservative voice who has received multiple awards for his opinion journalism. A native of Cleveland, Mr. Jacoby attended the Hebrew Academy of Cleveland. He graduated with honors from George Washington University in 1979 and from Boston University Law School in 1983.
Rabbi Avi Shafran, a musmach of Rav Yaakov Yitzchok Ruderman and a talmid of Rav Yaakov Weinberg, has served for the past 22 years as Agudath Israel of America’s spokesman and media liaison. He also pens a weekly opinion column for Hamodia, is a contributor to the Forward and Haaretz, and has written five books.
Marvin Schick has served for nearly half a century as the voluntary president of the Rabbi Jacob Joseph School, which now consists of five schools. Active in communal life since his teenage years, he was the principle founder and first president of the National Jewish Commission on Law and Public Affairs. He has written many hundreds of articles for the Jewish Press, Jewish Week, and other publications.
Binyamin Rose has been the news editor of Mishpacha since its inception in March 2004. He launched his journalism career in the 1970s, when reporters used typewriters and carbon paper, and is still going strong in the digital age, having traveled to over 20 countries on five continents to interview leading politicians and newsmakers.
Rabbi Sheftel Neuberger
First and foremost, a frum journalist must remain true to halachah. In the secular world, journalists are not circumscribed by the halachos of lashon hara or, for that matter, truth. The frum journalist has a responsibility to understand the Torah perspective on each issue he deals with and to communicate it in a way that people can understand and accept. He should, by all means, allow his Torah world view to color the way he reports the news.
Unfortunately, we live in a world that does not understand the real meaning of daas Torah. Daas Torah is a process, not a position. It is the process a Torah authority employs, using his Torah knowledge and scholarship, to arrive at a position on a given issue.
A frum journalist must avoid the pitfall of thinking his position or publication alone represents daas Torah, thus giving him the right to denigrate a contrary position held by others. Although we have a right to select which gadol b’Torah we consistently follow, we must be cognizant that the opposing view may well be a product of another gadol’s daas Torah. (Excerpted from Mishpacha, Issue 655)
To read more, subscribe to Mishpacha in print
Moshe Lax is in the diamond business. But really, he’s a musician who’s an author who’s a real estat...
Gianni Toso, one of the world’s leading glass artists, is as passionate about his art as he is about...
Yonatan and Aharon Razel, brothers with distinctive styles, have captured the spotlight of the Jewis...