Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter

The Law Is on the Rabbis’ Side

Yisrael Feller

Majority rule may be a cornerstone of democracy, but when it comes to the Kosel, the law is not on their side

Wednesday, June 28, 2017

 Mishpacha image

For now, this entrance to the Kosel says “men only.” Who will have the final say?

T he Reform and Conservative movements, at least in the United States, are fond of saying that they are the majority. That’s one argument they put forward to explain why they feel entitled to equal rights at the Western Wall, where Orthodox Jews pray.

Majority rule may be a cornerstone of democracy, but when it comes to the Kosel, the law is not on their side. Mishpacha obtained a 13-page document authored two months ago by attorneys Ze’ev Scharf and Yoav Levi of the Ze’ev Scharf and Company Law Offices, a Tel Aviv legal firm specializing in civil and commercial litigation.

Scharf and Levi contend that the “Protection of Holy Places” Law — which coincidentally took effect 50 years ago this week — designates the chief rabbinate as the authorized religious representative of the Jewish People in Israel, giving it final say in all matters at the Kosel.

Scharf and Levi argue that the law gives the chief rabbis the power to ask the Ministry of Religious Affairs, which implements the statute, to enact legal language that would prevent mixed prayer services at the Kosel. The attorneys cited a case from 1968, when Prime Minister Levi Eshkol turned down a request from Reform groups to pray at the Kosel. Eshkol based his decision, in part, on the fact that even under the British Mandate, the chief rabbinate oversaw religious affairs at the Kosel. This legal opinion undoubtedly explains why the chief rabbinate recently hardened its position on the issue of egalitarian prayer.

However, Prime Minister Netanyahu’s decision to freeze implementation of a longstanding cabinet agreement to create space at the Kosel for egalitarian prayer may only be temporary, despite media spin that Bibi caved to his chareidi coalition partners. Cabinet Secretary Tzachi Braverman clarified that it is important to Netanyahu that every Jew is able to pray at the Kosel. Work will continue to prepare the site near Robinson's Arch, at the Kosel's southern plaza, for mixed prayer. And while dialogue continues to reach a new compromise acceptable to all parties, Reform and Conservative groups may turn once again to the Supreme Court. And when that case is heard, the rabbinate may be silenced.

The Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee held spirited debate on the issue last week. Arguing for the Ministry of Justice, Rafi Neubauer told the committee that while his department “accords great importance to the stance of the chief rabbinate,” only the attorney general represents the government at the Supreme Court.

“The state speaks with one voice, and that’s the voice of the attorney general, who has the professional and legal experience,” Neubauer said.

However, the chief rabbinate insists it speaks for itself. Rabbi Raphael Frank, the secretary of the chief rabbinate and a senior advisor to Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi David Lau, told committee members: “Our concern is that the attorney general will dodge the central issue, which is our religious concerns. Our opinion may not suit their sensibilities, but we still ask that it be heard.”

Rabbi Uri Maklev (United Torah Judaism), who is a member of the Constitution, Law and Justice Committee, agrees that while the state should speak with one voice, when it comes to religious matters, it should defer to a higher authority.

Israel’s chief rabbis insist their voice be paramount on religious affairs

“Under the terms of employment at the Justice Ministry, there is no requirement that the attorney general be versed in halachah,” Rabbi Maklev said. “On the other hand, the chief rabbinate views the issue of prayer at the Kosel through the prism of halachah, maintaining from the start that the halachah does not contradict the law. So the rabbinate must have their own independent representative to argue before the courts on issues involving religious values.”

Rachel Azariah (Kulanu), who is also a member of the Constitution, Law, and Justice Committee, said the controversy reminded her of the Second Temple era, when a minority tried to foist its opinion on the majority. She accused chareidi parties, as well as Naftali Bennett’s Bayit Hayehudi, which supported Netanyahu's move to freeze implementation, of “creating a state within a state.”

Committee member Michael Malchieli (of Shas) fired back: “What you’re describing is the biryonim [hooligans] who used force to intimidate the rabbanim of that era. Today, the role of the biryonim is being filled by the Justice Ministry and attorney general. The whole argument boils down to whether the rabbinate or the attorney general is the final voice on religious affairs.” (Originally featured in Mishpacha, Issue 666)

Related Stories

A Red Line Crossed

Omri Nahmias, Washington, D.C.

Charity Ball Game Practice Becomes a Shooting Range

Tillerson in the Dark on Palestinian Payments?

Jacob Kornbluh

Payments to Terrorists Long-Term Capitol Hill Concern

Lifelines: Better Reception

C. Saphir

Who’s going to marry him? I asked myself. Who but I, the friend of the downtrodden, the patron of th...

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.

Hidden Power
Yonoson Rosenblum One never knows the power of his or her mitzvos
Can You Tell a Phony?
Eytan Kobre “You’re not using the phone; the phone is using you”
Grief and Gratitude
Yisroel Besser The deepest, most sophisticated truth in the world
Nobody's Perfect
Alexandra Fleksher With the gift of maturity, we learn to accept
Colossal Humility
Rabbi Ron Yitzchok Eisenman The last words I ever heard from my rebbi
Ready and Waiting
Baruch S. Fertel, MD, MPA, FACEP Why does everything take so long in the ER?
Bless You!
Faigy Peritzman Blessings don't create anything new in the natural world
Ready, Set, Succeed!
Sarah Chana Radcliffe Ensure success with explicit, doable instructions
The Radiance of Surrender
Mrs Shani Mendlowitz Honest admission reveals your inner radiance