Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter

Book of Records

Rabbi Eliyahu Gut

Arnold Zweig and Hermann Struck, two Jewish officers in the German army during World War I, discovered an old-new world: the Jewish shtetl, unchanged for centuries

Monday, September 18, 2017

 Mishpacha image

Coming from positions of privilege and enlightenment in Germany, Zweig and Struck had been conditioned to see the Orthodox Jews of Eastern Europe as a dying breed, miserable products of a backward society. What the two actually saw took their breath away

W orld War I, which started during the Nine Days of Av in 1914 and concluded with the armistice of November 1918, changed the face of the planet. Now, a century later, it is hard for us to recognize its significance: in the meantime humanity has endured World War II and the Holocaust, Communism and the Cold War, and the rise of Islamicism and mass terror. The Great War, the “War to End All Wars,” is enshrouded in the mists of history — yet it clearly set the stage for all that followed.

Besides the massive physical destruction, the war also broke down social barriers. It sparked a certain sense of adventure in the men who fought in it. As the British writer H.G. Wells put it in 1916, “This is the end and the beginning of an age. This is something far greater than the French Revolution or the Reformation and we live in it.”

Many young Jews in Western Europe were swept up in the call to arms. Having grown up under the benefits of the Enlightenment, they felt beholden to the lands of their birth and volunteered for military service along with their countrymen. In Germany, two such Jewish volunteers from different regions and backgrounds were thrown together in the Eastern Front. As German forces crossed over the frontiers of the Russian empire and occupied the territories of Poland and Lithuania, these two men would be brought face to face, for the first time, with the G-d-fearing Jews of Eastern Europe.

When the German army first appointed them liaisons to Jewish communities in the conquered lands, Arnold Zweig, a secular 29-year-old writer from Glogau in Prussian Silesia, and Hermann Struck, a 39-year-old religious Zionist artist from Berlin, had little enough in common with each other, much less with the pitiable, impoverished, Orthodox “Ostjuden” under their charge. Zweig was an intellectual who would go on to write dozens of works, earning numerous nominations for the Nobel Prize in Literature, and eventually become an ardent Communist. Struck was an accomplished artist known for his etchings, and also a cofounder of the Mizrachi movement in Germany; later in life he would move to Haifa. Article 1


Their posting to Eastern Europe gave them a common goal. The encounter would leave a lasting impression not only on Zweig and Struck but also on the Jews of the West. Zweig had begun his military service as a loyal Prussian patriot, but his experience with anti-Semitism in the army had soured him on German nationalism. On meeting his brethren in Poland and Lithuania, he came to see the war as pitting Jew against Jew. Struck’s official role was to influence the local Jews to remain neutral and not support the nationalistic Polish movements against the German occupiers. But he came to see it as a chance to help his brothers in Klal Yisrael.

Coming from positions of privilege and enlightenment in Germany, Zweig and Struck had been conditioned to see the Orthodox Jews of Eastern Europe as a dying breed, miserable products of a backward society. What the two actually saw took their breath away. Despite their desperate material circumstances, these Jews were far from miserable or backwards. The splendor of their authentic Judaism cast a light that enthralled these German officers.

Zweig and Struck decided to collaborate on a book, an eyewitness account that would eventually be published under the title Das Ostjüdische Antlitz (The Eastern-Jewish Face). Zweig, who knew barely anything at all about Judaism, penned the text. Struck provided the illustrations, faithfully portraying the characters he met in all the places he visited — Lodz, Vilna, Grodno, Bialystok, Kovna, and many more anonymous locales. His 52 drawings preserved for future generations the many personalities he came across: the tailor, the beggar, the watchmaker and the porter, the newspaper seller and the shoemaker, the shamash and the shopkeeper. (Excerpted from Mishpacha, Issue 678)

Related Stories

My Brother's Keeper

Gila Arnold

For these four families of accomplished Jews, one brother brought another… and sometimes yet another...

Biblical Proportions

Yonoson Rosenblum

Could Rabbi David Fohrman’s breezy style and animated videos elucidate the profoundest Torah concept...

Shaping Repentance from a Horn

C. S. Teitelbaum

What’s so special about Mr. Bengio’s shofros? Why are baalei tokeia scrupulous about purchasing only...

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.

When Tragedy Strikes
Shoshana Friedman What are we giving and what are we getting?
One Nation, Divisible
Yonoson Rosenblum Israel isn’t yet suffocated by political correctness
What Am I, Chopped Liver?
Eytan Kobre Far more disturbing is the title’s unspoken implication
Not Just Politics
Yisroel Besser We’re fighting over something that means the world to us
Are We There Yet?
Alexandra Fleksher Seeing other models of avodas Hashem enriches our own
Top 5 Yeshivish Business Ventures
Rabbi Dovid Bashevkin Different answers to “So, what is it you do?”
Work/Life Solutions with Mois Navon
Moe Mernick “When you set a goal, it’s going to take lots of effort”
Were They Orthodox Jews?
Rabbi Emanuel Feldman This is why I asked, “What difference does it make?”
You Get What You Pay For
Jacob L. Freedman “Get me a real doctor from Harvard who speaks Persian!”
Tunes That Take Me Back, with Levy Falkowitz
Riki Goldstein “It’s amazing how strong music memories are”
All Rivers Wind Up in the Sea
Riki Goldstein Your heartbeat will slow down listening to the new album
Faigy Peritzman A name symbolizes the essence inherent within
Sarah Chana Radcliffe Inject positivity into your marriage to counter burnout
The Game of Life
Rebbetzin Suri Gibber Use your competitive spirit to score high in life
The Musician Part II
D. Himy, M.S. CCC-SLP and Zivia Reischer “It’s an integrative therapy approach. Not boot camp”