Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter

Endnote: When Reb Abish Brodt Davens…

Riki Goldstein

Since 1983, Reb Abish’s name has been associated with the Regesh album series. These songs, composed by Rabbi Shmuel Brazil

Monday, September 18, 2017

 Mishpacha image


F or the Rebbe, Chaim Banet’s “Machnisei Rachamim” was double power

The emotional plea of “Machnisei Rachamim” is taken from one of the concluding sections of the Selichos, and Reb Chaim Banet, a chassid of Seret-Vizhnitz, says that his niggun to these words has gone further than he ever dreamed.

“When I composed “Machnisei Rachamim,” we sang it with the choir for the Rebbe ztz”l, and he gestured to me, ‘zing es nochamul — sing it again.’ The day after that Motzaei Shabbos of Selichos, the Rebbe called me over to explain to me that there are tunes that are powerful without words, like the Chabad ‘Daled Bavos’ niggun and the Karlin ‘Kah Echsof,’ and there are also words that are so powerful that they need no tune. Here, he said, both the words and the niggun were special.

“Back then it was a brand-new composition,” Banet continues. “I myself didn’t know it was something special. Now, years later, when so many people are continuously inspired, by that niggun, to tefillah and connection, especially during the Yamim Noraim, I finally understand the koach that the Rebbe understood immediately.” 



Meshulam Greenberger’s niggun of hope

The Toldos Aharon Rebbe recently spent a Shabbos with 100 of his yungeleit in Tzfas. When he left the room, the group began to sing Meshulam Greenberger’s popular new “Mah Tishtochachi Nafshi,” a slow, moving song with a complex structure of several parts, which has become a choir favorite in the months since its release on Greenberger’s newest album, Oscha Avakesh. Upon the Rebbe’s return, the young men stopped singing, since he does not usually approve of contemporary music. But the Rebbe motioned them to continue. And when the song finished, he spoke for an hour, expounding on the song’s words taken from Tehillim 42:12 — “Why are you downcast my soul, and why are you disquieted? Hope to Hashem, for I will yet thank Him for the salvations of my countenance and my G-d.”

How Shloime Dachs discovered “Chamol”

“I was a bochur learning in Eretz Yisrael when I was invited by to a seudah at the home of musician and producer Suki Berry. We were at the Shabbos table, and Rabbi Akiva Homnick, who lived nearby, came in and joined us. I heard him sing ‘Chamol Al Maasecha,’ and I was instantly struck by the song’s power and beauty. I purchased the song then, and several years later, in 1996, after I was already married, I was indeed zocheh to bring it out on my first album, One Day at a Time. What a zechus it is for me to have been the shaliach to introduce such a powerful song that is sung throughout the world on the Yamim Noraim.” 

When Reb Abish Brodt Davens, Everyone Looks in the Machzor 

For Reb Abish Brodt, this year will be different. After 30 years as the shaliach tzibbur in Agudas Yisroel Bais Binyomin in Flatbush, his move to Lakewood means a change of amud. Reb Abish treasures the opportunity to lead the Yom Tov tefillos. Until recently, he was the baal Shacharis and baal Mussaf at two different shuls on Rosh Hashanah, and led Maariv, Mussaf, and Ne’ilah on Yom Kippur.

He explains the origins of his well-loved nusach. “My family comes from Mielec in Galicia, close to the Sanz area. Most of my nusach is that which I heard from my father and is based on the Ropshitzer heritage, but over the years it’s been influenced by the davening in the yeshivos. When I was young, I davened in Bais Medrash Elyon. I was only 13 or 14, but until today I can hear the hergesh of Rav Simcha Schustal ztz”l. You had to hear how he began the brachah of Avos with such passion. Some people today underrate that first brachah, and make the mistake of skimming through it, but Avos is the basis of the whole tefillah — you have to feel that. On other occasions, I heard the previous Stuchiner Rebbe ztz”l daven. The Rebbe was an unforgettable baal tefillah — it was obvious to anyone who listened that he felt the weight of what he was saying.”

The crowd in shul wait for their familiar, favorite pieces, and Reb Abish likes to keep his nusach and tunes the same from year to year so that they can join in the davening. “The shaliach tzibbur has to daven with the oilem, not at the oilem,” he says. While one or two new tunes add freshness, more would disappoint. He explains that the world has now adopted many niggunim that originated in the various yeshivos — for example, the “Ki Hinei Kachomer” composed by the famed baal tefillah Rav Herschel Goldstein and adopted by Rav Sholom Schwadron was first used in the Chevron yeshivah back in the 1950s, and has spread widely from there.

Today, Reb Abish’s sons are popular baalei tefillah in their own right. “They are all accomplished baalei tefillah, and yes, they use mostly my nusach. But each has changed certain parts, and rightfully so. A baal tefillah has to make the davening his own. You can’t copy someone or try to be someone else. You have to be comfortable with the nusach in order to deliver the message.”

Since 1983, Reb Abish’s name has been associated with the Regesh album series. These songs, composed by Rabbi Shmuel Brazil, include such classic favorites as “Shalom Aleichem,” “Kavei El Hashem,” and “Modeh Ani Lefanecha,” and have been popular for years, thanks to Reb Abish’s trademark voice and hartzige style. On Yamim Noraim, Regesh songs “Kevakoras” (Regesh Vol. 5) and “Selach Na” (Regesh Vol. I) have become popular davening niggunim.

“In a certain shul where I served as baal Mussaf many years ago, there was a strong tendency to take out a sefer and learn during chazaras hashatz,” Reb Abish remembers. “One year after davening, my young son let me know, ‘Tatty, everyone was looking in the machzor this time.’ It was the ultimate compliment.” (Originally featured in Mishpacha, Issue 678)

Related Stories

Cut ’N Paste: How’s My Dancing?

Zechariah Saltman

Once you’ve stepped on a considerable number of feet, you can simply repeat the same exact steps ove...

The Best Defense

Aryeh Ehrlich

According to the Biala Rebbe of Bnei Brak, we’re a worthy generation that engages in Torah and chese...

The Current: Year in Review 5777

Binyamin Rose

The major news stories of the past year

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.

Seventy Years
Rabbi Moshe Grylak “The sword from without, and machlokes from within”
Helping Our Kids Find Their Mission
Yonoson Rosenblum The best home protection against the “foreign winds”
Meeting for Minchah
Eytan Kobre “A Ten-Minute Appointment for a Five-Minute Encounter”
Top 5 Jewish Grammar Mistakes
Rabbi Dovid Bashevkin Seeing the errors of our grammatical ways
The Missing Alef
Alef is not simply another letter in the Hebrew alphabet
What Are You Grateful For?
Jacob L. Freedman “I guess all we can do is to be grateful”
A Simple Offering
Faigy Peritzman Our obligations are measured according to our abilities
Building a Better Brain
Sarah Chana Radcliffe Make your home an emotionally safe place to be real
The Cyclist: Part III
D. Himy, M.S. CCC-SLP and Zivia Reischer Rachel has advanced from “flustered” to “determined”
Wholly Holy
Rebbetzin Aviva Feiner Realize who you are and how you can impact this world