Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter



Yonah: The Grand Finale?

Osher Chaim Levene

In the relentless battlefield of life, man has to choose good and reject evil. But there are two options regarding what to do with that evil

Wednesday, September 27, 2017

mishpacha image

G-d wanted to teach Yonah that, in this world, no one is yet at a level to fully withstand the scorching fury of pure, unadulterated justice, as symbolized by the mighty, unrelenting rays of the sun. Everyone needs to seek a temporary shelter or refuge — evoking the image of the succah that offers shade from the sunlight

T he mysterious ending of the Book of Yonah has left many a reader perplexed. The story, on the whole, is well known. Having miraculously survived being cast into the depths of the sea after Hashem summoned a tempest to strike his ship, Yonah was swallowed by a large fish, and his prayers recited from within its belly were answered. He was returned to dry land to dutifully complete the mission of spurring the masses of the great city of Nineveh to repent.

But the story does not end there.

It reverts back to the eponymous prophet, who was furious with Hashem for accepting Nineveh’s repentance — which was the reason why he had originally fled. Responding to his death wish, Hashem questions Yonah about his anger. Setting up a succah to the east of the city, Yonah sits in the sun’s shade to watch the city’s fate.

Later, Hashem prepares the kikayon (gourd) plant to cover him. But his delight is short-lived. A worm attacks the kikayon, causing it to wither. Growing faint from the rising sun and east wind, once again, Yonah asks to die. Hashem questions Yonah about his anger. Did he not experience a sense of compassion for the kikayon despite not having worked or grown it? But was not the kikayon a fleeting creation — a “son of night” that emerged unexpectedly, but then was lost? So, too, questions Hashem: “Should I not likewise feel pity for the great city of Nineveh, with its 120,000 inhabitants, who don’t know difference between right and left, and much cattle?” The Book of Yonah abruptly ends with this rhetorical question.

What lies behind this closing chapter? Why was Yonah so aggravated with Nineveh’s wave of repentance that he asked to die? What lies behind the prophet’s short-lived joy at the kikayon’s temporary shelter from the sun, only for it to wither after being struck by a worm?

Rav Moshe Dovid Valle ztz”l, a discipline of the Ramchal, explains how the finale to Book of Yonah is not an epilogue but a commentary on the whole story. It explores the uneasy relationship between the Jewish People (symbolized by Yonah) and the gentile nations (Nineveh) and sheds light on why sinners are afforded mercy, which enables them to avert (or at least postpone) being brought to justice, insofar as repentance for past evil deeds can cause them to be transformed into a vehicle for good.

How Best to Defeat Evil?

There is a fundamental ideological question about how to confront evil. In the relentless battlefield of life, man has to choose good and reject evil. But there are two options regarding what to do with that evil.

The first approach is that of destruction, requiring man to eradicate evil in whatever shape or form, until there is no remembrance, because it is irredeemable. This approach requires ruthlessness and strict justice.

The second path is that of transformation, whereby one takes control over what was originally evil and turns it into something good. A government official, for example, might spare a treacherous spy to retrain him and put him to work for his side. But this approach requires applying mercy and granting permission for teshuvah, repentance.3 In general, Hashem prefers the wicked to repent and live rather than to be punished and die. 

 

Excerpted from Mishpacha, Issue 679. Osher Chaim Levene is director of Orah–London and author of several works including Jewish Wisdom in the Numbers (with Rabbi Yehoshua Hartman, ArtScroll/Mesorah

Related Stories

The Words They Need to Hear

Rav Eliyahu Gut and Rav Ephraim Galinsky

Rav Moshe Elazar Lipka, who followed Rav Yisrael Zeev Gustman ztz”l to Eretz Yisrael, shares memorie...

Higher & Higher

Shraga Simmons

Nineteen years ago, Rabbi Doniel Katz didn’t have a single Jewish friend. Today, he leads Elevation,...

An Idea Whose Time Has Come

Project Coordinator: Rachel Bachrach

Kosher pizza, hat-shaped hatboxes, bike-a-thons, group flights to seminary, snoods… Who are the inno...

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.
CAPTCHA
Message


MM217
 
A Response to "Too Far from Home"
Rabbi Moshe Grylak “Chareidi Israel is not happy to absorb immigrants”
Life after Kollel
Yonoson Rosenblum Remaining a ben Torah requires remaining a bar daas
Angel's Advocate
Eytan Kobre Because this is how’s it’s supposed to be always
Make Your Words Count
Rabbi Shneur Aisenstark This story delivers two sobering lessons for all of us
I Know of What I Speak
Rabbi Ron Yitzchok Eisenman I would allow my mask to fall, my soul to be revealed
Meet the Tzaddik
Jacob L. Freedman “Aren’t there meds that can get him back to yeshivah?”
Two centuries later, the Chasam Sofer’s niggunim are heard again
Riki Goldstein The musical side of the Chasam Sofer dynasty
How Do You Think of These Words?
Riki Goldstein “For me, the words are the neshamah of the song”
The Song I Can't Stop Singing: Shlomo Simcha
Riki Goldstein “Which song are you connecting to this season?”
Megama Had the Magic
Riki Goldstein Remembering Moshe Yess a”h and Shalom Levine a”h
Living Beyond the Moment
Faigy Peritzman Someone steeped in Torah always lives beyond the moment
Uncertainty
Sarah Chana Radcliffe We can only be sure that we can never be sure
Instinctive Knowledge
With Rav Moshe Wolfson, written by Baila Vorhand Jewish babies are born knowing Hashem
The Gardener: Part II
D. Himy, M.S. CCC-SLP and Zivia Reischer “It’s a secret language called body language”