Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter



The Opinionator: Does Israel Have a Moral Responsibility to Accept Asylum Seekers?

Gedalia Guttentag

“The left are fake humanitarians; they’re not doing this to help the migrants, they’re doing this to change the Jewish demographics of the country”

Wednesday, January 31, 2018

 Mishpacha image

 

W hen three El Al pilots refused to fly African refugees out of Israel, the asylum issue was back in the news. From 2007 to 2012, some 60,000 Eritreans and Sudanese illegally entered Israel. Massing in South Tel Aviv, they drove up crime and made neighborhood locals feel like strangers.

Israel’s new immigration law gives asylum seekers a stark choice: either voluntarily leave for their countries of origin or a “third party” state, with airfare paid, plus a $3,500 grant — or face deportation. (The third parties mentioned most often are Rwanda and Uganda, which have allegedly cut deals with Israel to accept the migrants.)


Does Israel, as a Jewish country, have a moral responsibility to accept asylum seekers?

Knowing that this is a hot-button issue related to different conceptions of modern Israel, we turned to a range of people across the political spectrum. As expected, it provoked fierce debate.


MK Michal Rozin (Meretz) chair, Committee on Foreign Workers 2013-2015

Obviously our own people come first. One’s community, family — that’s natural. But call it tikkun olam — what differentiates humans from other creatures is taking care of others.

As Jews and Israelis, victims of anti-Semitism, we have a special responsibility not to treat people as “the other.” The comparisons that are made to the Holocaust [by people advocating an open-door policy] are not referring to Treblinka, but rather to the way it began at the beginning of the 1930s, with no place of refuge for Jews.

Now, I don’t have a problem with sending people to a third country. My point is that those sent to Rwanda find themselves in jail with no status, and have to run again. Over 80 migrants who eventually made it to Europe have testified to that.

I asked Netanyahu why the government made a secret agreement with the third countries, but got no answer. The Rwandans deny having an agreement, the government says there is. Who’s lying — the government of Israel, or Rwanda?

Finally, besides these migrants from Africa, there are more than 100,000 other non-Jewish workers in the country illegally. They happened to have entered through the airport, not the southern border. If it’s the demographic threat to Israel you’re worried about, are these other illegal foreigners not as dangerous? Why are they not prosecuted? Is it because they’re not black? Let’s say it out loud: It’s all racist.


May Golan, CEO of the Hebrew City NGO and anti-immigration activist

The comparison to the Holocaust that you hear is a disgrace. In Europe, Jews were shot and buried in mass graves — is this what we’re doing?

Obviously, Israel as a Jewish country has the moral sense to accept refugees. The fact is that Sudanese from Darfur have been granted asylum. But the Eritreans are economic migrants. That’s accepted by the UK, by Norway, and by Israel’s Supreme Court. It’s safe for them to go back, and certainly safe for them to go to Rwanda and other countries.

I just care about my 70-year-old mother who has to live in fear in South Tel Aviv. There used to be 30 cops in the area — now there are 300. Why? Because these illegal migrants have brought crime. I will not suffer for them just to have better economic lives. The left are fake humanitarians; they’re not doing this to help the migrants, they’re doing this to change the Jewish demographics of the country. (Excerpted from Mishpacha, Issue 696)

Related Stories

Rose Report: Poland Detached from Its Past

Binyamin Rose

Proposed Holocaust law punishes discussions of Polish guilt

Washington Wrap: Dazzling and Dauntless in Davos

Omri Nahmias

Trump the tycoon surprises Davos Man

The Explainer: A Deadline for DACA looms

Omri Nahmias

Will Congress stump up for Trump’s border wall to protect the Dreamers?

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.
CAPTCHA
Message


MM217
 
Not a Newspaper
Shoshana Friedman A deeper difference between newspapers and magazines
Services in Shards
Rabbi Moshe Grylak “Such a painful, malicious lie!”
The Pittsburgh Protests: All Politics All the Time
Yonoson Rosenblum The old rule — “no enemies on the left” — still applies
Danger: School Crossing
Eytan Kobre The hypocrisy of YAFFED’s assertion is breathtaking
Real Laughter and Real Tears
Rabbi Avrohom Neuberger The two sides of a life lived with emunah
Work/Life Solutions with Eli Langer
Moe Mernick I was proud to be “that guy with the yarmulke”
Is Ktchong! a Mitzvah? When Prayer and Charity Collide
Rabbi Emanuel Feldman These cannot both be done effectively at the same time
An Honest Shidduch
Jacob L. Freedman “Baruch Hashem I’m cured, and this will be my secret”
A Blessing in Disguise
Riki Goldstein “I never thought the song would catch on as it has”
Ishay and Motti Strike a Common Chord
Riki Goldstein Bringing together two worlds of Jewish music
What’s your favorite Motzaei Shabbos niggun?
Riki Goldstein From the holy and separate back to the mundane
Rightfully Mine
Faigy Peritzman Don’t regret the job you didn’t land; it was never yours
Growing Greener Grass
Sarah Chana Radcliffe Nurture your blessings and watch them blossom
My Way or the High Way
Rebbetzin Debbie Greenblatt We know what we want — but do we know what He wants?